Sep. 4th, 2021

jsburbidge: (Default)

The Toronto Star had a front-page article with the title "Why is Everyone So Angry?" (well, third page with a massive banner on the front page). Unfortunately, its diagnosis was facile.

It was clearly prompted by the phenomenon of Justin Trudeau being regularly assailed viciously, and in such numbers, that in one case he had to cancel an appearance (as the protestors outnumbered the police).

(As a specific phenomenon this is a little odd. After all, when you think of it, Trudeau is in many ways the Jim Hacker of Canadian politics: appeal to the public, not very bright, steered by his advisors. You may be assured that anything he backs will have come from either the party or the civil service or (most likely) both, without being so extreme to be able to be called "courageous".

Although the Conservative Party condemns the behaviour, it feeds it by running so emphatically against Trudeau, as though the government's policies all sprang from his forehead. The PMO may be at least as dictatorial as it was under Harper - there has been no return to Cabinet government[1] - but it is hardly a hotbed of flourishing originality and exciting ideas.)

But the anti-vax, anti-mask movement in particular is pretty well frothing at the lips. Why?

The article points all of its fingers at pandemic fatigue. It omits noting that Brexit, and the Trump election, and for that matter the Tea Party formation around 2008, were all driven by a similar type of anger. Covid-19 has provided a couple of new presenting issues, and pandemic fatigue is undoubtedly an aggravating factor, but it's hardly the most important one.

(If it were pure pandemic fatigue you'd expect a cadre of vaccinated people who are fed up with the risks posed by unvaccinated people and heckle candidates who are "soft" on vaccine mandates balancing out the anti-vaxxers protesting the Liberals; and you'd expect protestors in the anti-vax, anti-mask camps to protest the federal Conservatives as well, as they have moved to avoid having any significant space between the Liberals and themselves on this issue.)

My interpretation is that it's an effect of cognitive dissonance with transferred anger. People don't want to acknowledge that things will never revert to where they were in (choose one based on your issue) 2019, 2000, 1989, 1981, 1966, or 1958.[2]

If that's something you won't acknowledge, to the level of cognitive dissonance, then displacing the anger at life moving away from where you are convinced it ought to be is a direct effect. (This is also tied up with confronting, or avoiding confronting, the fact that your idea of "rights" does not line up with that of the law.)

Also, naturally, even people with a much milder degree of denial will be attracted to an appeal of return. The natural heirs are parties of the right, as their natural platforms involve either minimizing or denying the necessity of significant change.

All of this feeds into the election dynamic. The Liberals suffer from both kinds of reaction; the CPC benefits. Maxime Bernier's party is showing a small uptick.

A secondary effect is that although climate is a potential wedge issue - the potential wedge issue - between the CPC and the Liberals, it's not being used as such, because to run a campaign on that basis amounts to repeatedly telling people that they haven't seen real disruptive change yet, and that they need to get ready for it and support it. In the current context that is probably not a way to win middle-of-the-road voters, who are the key group in this election.

It is still possible for the CPCs to end up failing to form a government, especially if (as Singh advertised in the spring) the NDP refuses to support the CPC in a minority government. Unless things improve greatly for the Liberals, though, it is probably time to write Trudeau's political obituary, given both the drop in support and the fact that it was ultimately Trudeau's decision to call this particular election in the first place.

[1]I remember Gordon, LaMarsh, Trudeau, Pelletier, and Marchand.

[2] Pre-Covid, pre-9/11, before the fall of the Soviet block, pre-IBM PC, pre-New Left, before the shine came off the suburbs.

Profile

jsburbidge: (Default)
jsburbidge

April 2025

S M T W T F S
  12345
67 89101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930   

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 9th, 2025 08:12 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios